Welcome!  We are a Christian community very much like Fayetteville today, a mix of the old and the new! 

Our beautiful church is centrally located in the heart of historic downtown Fayetteville, North Carolina. Hay Street United Methodist Church was dedicated in June of 1835. Our main building features a large sanctuary with beautiful stained glass memorial windows which were made in Salisbury, England in 1907 and original brass chandeliers. 

Our beautiful memorial prayer chapel opened December 14, 1954 and was created in memory of Mary Fields Jones, a church member.  It is the perfect setting for private wedding ceremonies and baptisms. This chapel features high ceilings, original chandeliers, beautiful stained glass windows and a lovely organ.

 Our bell that hangs in the tower was purchased in 1868. Our organ is a two-manual console with tracker action, installed in 1978. Variations in tonal quality are regulated by 24 stops, which control 1,653 pipes!

Our building features a beautifully designed fellowship hall, a full sized gym, a library, and a preschool. Our wonderful gym, located on the 2nd floor is the perfect place to host private ball games and dances and our fellowship hall is a wonderful setting for large meetings, dinners and private functions. Our facilities are available for community use, and we have the ability to accommodate 150 comfortably!  

We offer two Sunday Services, our Blended Contemporary Worship Service begins at 9:00 am and our Traditional Worshop Service begins at 11 am. Both services feature beautiful music in a gorgeous restored church setting.  You will feel the spirt of the “old and the new” when you become a part of this Christ centered church.